Saturday, October 3, 2009

The Horse Boy (2009)

(The Horse Boy was one of four films screened on Poterero Avenue on the evenings of September 23rd and 24th. Reviews of the other three films will be published here soon.)

The Horse Boy is a ninety-three minute documentary by Austin, Texas-based filmmaker Michel O. Scott which unfortunately feels much longer. Its story is an intriguing one, ostensibly brimming with love and hope. The Horse Boy is produced and narrated by the film's star, Austin journalist, writer and father, Rupert Isaacson, and the tale is based on his book, “The Horse Boy: A Father's Quest to Heal His Son.” The book and now film chronicle Isaacson's journey to Mongolia with his wife and young autistic son Rowan in the effort to find shamans who, the father hopes, may heal him.

The genesis of the trip was the son's usually dyspeptic demeanor, punctuated by seemingly endless tantrums, one day becoming singularly serene whenever he rode a neighbor's horse named Betsy. Whenever the child rode atop Betsy, he seemed remarkably peaceful. Isaacson considered this and coupled his own experience with the Bushmen of Africa, related in his 2004 book, “The Healing Land: The Bushmen and the Kalahari Desert.” Isaacson's research pointed to the Mongolians as having the longest history of using horses, so he coupled the knowledge he gained from his sojourn to see the Bushmen with the Mongolian shamans who, like the Bushmen, spiritually healed those addled by disease. Isaacson convinced his comparatively skeptical wife to take the journey to Mongolia to see the shamans based on these points. The documentary unfortunately does not address why this seemingly radical alternative to the western medication the Isaacsons use on a daily basis must be taken. The correlation between the African Bushmen and the Mongolian shamans remains tenuous. Could, for instance, the child have been escorted to an American Indian tribal medicine man closer to the Isaacsons' home of Austin? Rowan's reaction to the horse, which spurred Isaacson to take this action, may be explainable as simply a child's innate affection for the animal, and for something new. If Rowan's reaction is indeed quite significant, it would be helpful for the documentary to more greatly illuminate, on autism in general and Rowan's case in particular.

The film makes no clear comparisons between Rowan and other autistic children. Autism itself is very briefly covered, with gradations momentarily discussed, but Rowan's case is never directly scientifically scrutinized in relation to other cases of autism. The Horse Boy uses a multi-person panel of apparent experts in the field of autism including Austin psychotherapist Dale Rudin to expound various thoughts and postulations concerning the disease. The soundbites from the rotating doctors often contradict one another. The specifics of autism as a disease, even in relation to Rowan himself, are left frustratingly muddled. This is not entirely unreasonable unto itself yet the myriad comments are often vague or cliché-ridden. Those with a genuine interest in autism, such as beleaguered parents with autistic children of their own, will probably be rather disappointed by The Horse Boy's regrettably shallow pseudo-intellectualism.

The Horse Boy, as a documentary, sadly lacks much in the way of documentation—aside from the trip the Isaacsons take, it documents little. Evidence, examples, basic factual support are all conspicuously missing. This damages the cinematic missive; while it is obvious Rowan has been diagnosed as autistic, what does this truly entail? The lack of answers leaves The Horse Boy appearing woefully incondite at times. The film, through the patriarchal Isaacson, does relate that Rowan suffers from interminable and inconsolable tantrums, an inability to relate to or play with other children, and severe bowel incontinence. (The documentary pushes the audience's patience and embarrassment with at least one too many sequence detailing the latter symptom.) One overwhelming problem with the film, however, is that Rowan's autism is displayed in disparate contexts. In one scene, Isaacson expresses wonderment and happiness when his son throws a tantrum apparently because he was being separated from the shamans. Isaacson notes that this is a good sign; he believed his son would probably throw a tantrum when he was placed near the shamans. Does this comport with average autistic children? Are their symptoms chiefly brought about by emotional reactions?

This gleeful shedding of concrete, rational science as part of the potential equation extends to the Isaacsons readily accepting the shamans' belief, upon examining the family, that a “dark spirit” entered the womb of Isaacson's wife, Kristin Neff. Neff, with an earned Ph.D. in Human Development from Berkeley, rarely receives the focus of The Horse Boy; the picture either occludes or limits all other voices but Isaacson's own. Neff does briefly relate that her deceased, mentally unstable grandmother, the “dark spirit” of whom the shamans speak, suffered from manic depression and this “spirit”/genetic history has directly led to her son's autism. Rowan's parents subject themselves to ritualistic whippings by the shamans, compelled to not scream lest the ceremony be for naught. While the shamans' rituals are displayed visually for the film, the reasoning behind them are left vague. Likewise, Isaacson endeavors to lunge at various other possibilities of healing, including recuperative springs and visiting the “Reindeer People” of Mongolia. Isaacson's open faith may or may not be laudatory, but these developments in the documentary's narrative make the picture rather arduous with only the vistas of beautiful, wondrously open and commodious Mongolian terrain providing steady relief.

Almost humorously, or simply embarrassingly, Isaacson is depicted as hopelessly naïve in his own inexperienced impression of Mongolia, and especially of the Mongolian capital of Ulaanbaatar, a desolate, chalky city packed with impoverished slums. After landing in the benighted city, Isaacson confesses that this reality is not what he was remotely expecting in his apparent fantasy of Mongolia. In one of the rare piercing comments made by Neff, she confirms this. The Horse Boy, as composed by filmmaker Scott, seems to relish the thoroughly “open-minded” Isaacson's lack of basic prudence—partly as romanticization, but perhaps more calculatedly as celebrating the prime mover of the “plot”—at the expense of greater insights into the more intriguing subject matter that is largely unexplored. While personalizing the film is necessary when dealing with such inherently intimate subject matter, the film never quite becomes more than validation for Isaacson. Consequently, best intentions notwithstanding, it never presents itself with the compelling, involving urgency that best suits the cinema.

20 comments:

matt said...

well put

Books, said...

Alexander said,
Those with a genuine interest in autism, such as beleaguered parents with autistic children of their own, will probably be rather disappointed by The Horse Boy's regrettably shallow pseudo-intellectualism.


Hi! Alexander,
I wonder what could have made this film a four star film...instead of, a two in a half-star film? (Well, I ‘am actually basing my ”star” rating of the film The Horse Boy on your critique of the film nothing more or nothing less…)

Perhaps, if the director (or writer(s) had focused more on the positive points that you have pointed out to your readers about the film The Horse Boy…it probably would had been a more interesting film.

Wow, ninety-three minutes...still after reading your review I ‘am most definitely, not in a hurry to add The Horse Boy to my list of must-see films.

On the other hand, at least your review is very "straightforward" and in the end, very informative,and very well written…as usual.

Thanks, for sharing!
DeeDee ;-D

Books, said...

"I most definitely, will be looking forward to reading your review of the film The Horse Boy. (Oh! no, I have never watched the film,..."
This is still true!...

(The Horse Boy) but I cannot wait for an "introduction.")

Hmmm... Alexander, I think that I'am "rethinking" my last sentence.

DeeDee ;-D

Anonymous said...

i had no idea what this movie was about when i read the title but if its a documentary and this guy is sending his son to shamans half way around the world to get cured then i would believe the director is making fun of the guy a little. does the movie focus more on the autistic son or the father. good review alex, i will be sure to miss this film when it comes out later.

cineaste said...

one of the most sickeningly overrated movies of the year. what a waste of time and bore this is. great review by someone who calls it like it is.

Alexander Coleman said...

DeeDee and Sam, thank you for the highly thoughtful comments with regards to this review of a film with which I did indeed have many problems.

Viagra Online said...

I knew about a cute horse that was named the most beautiful name ever. I think the name had to do something with the universe or so the thing is that I love riding horses.

Anonymous said...

oh.
charm braceletsrolex replica watches for sale
Charm attachment by our Professional Jewelers is available at checkout. We will attach your bracelet and charms using the best possible arrangement, or you can request a special arrangement for our Jewelers to attach them in by requesting the charm order in our comments box at checkout.

chip said...

Perhaps, if the director (or writer(s) had focused more on the positive points that you have pointed out to your readers about the film The Horse Boy…it probably would had been a more interesting film.natural infertility treatmentsProfessional Recruitment For Candidates

GameforYou said...

The 27 consonants of the Lao alphabet are divided into three tone classes—high (ສູງ [sǔːŋ]), middle (ກາງ [kaːŋ]), low (ຕ່ຳ tām)—which determine the tonal pronunciation of the word in conjunction with the four tone marks and distinctions between short and long vowels, but aside from tone, there are 21 distinct consonant sounds that occur in the Lao language. Each letter has an acrophonical name that either begins with or features the word prominently and is used to teach the letter and serves to distinguish them from other, homophonous consonants. The letter ອ is a special null consonant used as an anchor for vowels, which cannot stand alone, as well as serves as a vowel in its own right.
Chevron Island Real Estate
legetøj

blogcar said...

Azt mondják, hogy “A nemzeti együttműködés kormánya nem a
megszorításokra építi a gazdaságpolitikáját!”
vitaminsoc cosmetic dentist

blogcar said...

CSIS head urged government to fight ban on information obtained through torture
MLS.ca Mississaugabreast enhancement herbs

blogcar said...

Google has launched a pilot program that will let owners of Google+ Pages manage their accounts via third-party apps such as Hootsuite.
chiropractor Maroubratop New York Salons

quan said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ckutude said...

That's got to be the tiniest Octopus I've ever seen.
Best At Home Teeth Whitening Kitssteroides anabolisants shop

trung said...

iphone 4 screen repairsuccess coaching
You need to know your friends
I'll be waving my hand watching you drown
Watching you scream
Quiet or loud
Maybe you should sleep
Maybe you just need a friend

mantr said...

custom home design brisbaneHämorrhoiden Behandlung
I don't believe in Buddha
I don't believe in mantra
I don't believe in Gita
I don't believe in yoga
I don't believe in kings
I don't believe in Elvis
I don't believe in Zimmerman
I don't believe in Beatles
I just believe in me
Yoko and me
And that's reality

createforumsfree said...

If you follow these tips, you will gain new visitors to your website. More people will read your
articles, and you will get more attention from the public. If you write many high-quality articles,
you will boost your sales volume.
new cancer treatmentsTummy Tuck

uknowme said...

If you follow these tips, you will gain new visitors to your website. More people will read your
articles, and you will get more attention from the public. If you write many high-quality articles,
you will boost your sales volume.
fake watch

text free

cheap prom dresses said...

That day, I came to my house in quiet and very soon, as that will surprise you with just bought loaf. My birthday. I was sleeping, I know that.