Wednesday, April 1, 2009

The Night They Raided Minsky's (1968)


The Night They Raided Minsky's is an appropriate film to look over on April Fools' Day, as its narrative hinges on one large “trick” to be played on certain characters. William Friedkin's second feature film is an uneven but sweet and charming ode to the 1920s theaters of burlesque. As the film today exists in current form, it routinely cuts away from his own narrative and splices in many apparent pieces of footage from the time period itself, thick with grain and washed-out images. The screenplay, based on a book by Rowland Barber and written by Arnold Schulman, Sidney Michaels and Norman Lear, supplies a dangerously thin storyline, but the film is at its most fun when the mechanics of the picture are almost invisible, and mere gags and burlesque performances take the center stage.
Jason Robards, who plays central figure Raymond Paine, received mixed notices for The Night They Raided Minsky's, but today his performance seems stronger than it may have at the time of the film's release. Robards was never too much of a “leading man movie star” to diminish his own self-effacing and auto-critiquing tendencies; even in the testosterone-laden westerns in which he appeared, he often played characters either physically or psychologically wounded, such as the contemporaneous Once Upon a Time in the West, Hour of the Gun or The Ballad of Cable Hogue. With Minsky's, Robards allows his most winning attributes to mesh with his nearly continual semblance of debilitation—ever so slightly suave, his persona is crushed when confronted with hostility or projected dubiousness by others. It helps that Robards is given many of the film's best lines. When his longtime partner and friend, Chick Williams (an energetic Norman Wisdom), falls for the pulchritudinous Amish ingénue, Rachel Elizabeth Schpitendavel (a wide-eyed Britt Ekland), Robards' roguish huckster comedian undermines Chick's propriety. )(Which ties into their joined rendition of “Perfect Gentleman,” in which Robards' character sings along with Wisdom's about just how much of a gentleman he is. “You suffer from the three D's,” Raymond tells Chick, “you're decent, devoted and dependable. Good qualities in a dog—disastrous in a man.” He goes on: “Women love bastards. I am a BFC: Bastard First Class.” Robards likewise shines in a long scene in which he approaches a woman at the local deli—where a significant portion of the film's events take place—only to be surprised when her husband returns from the restroom. So Raymond smooth-talks the husband and is as smooth as the skin of a newborn. The humor is obvious but Robards is too excellent when at his best in this film to dismiss, balancing his motor-mouthed shtick with the fearfulness behind it.

Ekland is fine as the young runaway Amish woman who is blinded by the dazzling marquee. As Raymond and Chick contest one another over her affections, Ekland's debatable one-note performance never feels particularly calculated, which is key in making it fit with the long line of young ingénues who were transfixed on the idea of becoming a star of show-business. Considered unqualified for burlesque, Ekland's Rachel is manipulated by the scheming Raymond; his bright idea is to have her perform one night after being billed as “Mademoiselle Fifi,” the French starlet and heroine of pornographic literature, who is, it is constantly noted in her billing, “The Girl Who Drove a Thousand Frenchmen Wild.” Raymond figures Rachel will do what she has done in her Pennsylvania Amish community—perform a Biblical dance rather than a bawdy number. Thus, Secretary for the Suppression of Vice Vance Fowler (Denholm Elliott), determined to raid Minsky's in the event of Mademoiselle Fifi's appearance, will have no reason to shut the establishment down and Raymond's job will be safe.
Two other welcome performers are Joseph Wiseman and Elliot Gould as the father and son (Louis and Billy Minsky), who repeatedly enliven the picture. Wiseman and Gould play their parts as Jewish businessmen with significant emphasis on their ethnicity. The Night They Raided Minsky's pokes some fun at religion in general, as Rachel's stern and unforgiving Amish father, Jacob Schpitendavel (Harry Andrews), hunt her down and finally finds himself confronted with Wiseman's Louis Minsky. Louis educating two other religious men about the identities of each finger's meaning in religious terminology evokes laughter. The picture may satirize stoically religious individuals, but at this late point in the film, it does so with a genial warmth.

The Night They Raided Minsky's was released just as Hollywood films had largely been let loose; censorship in American cinema was coming to an end. So it is particularly amusing to view Minsky's as the film examines a different kind of show-biz thriving under the threatening thumb of censorship. As Elliott's Fowler chastises the men who run Minsky's, he is asked what he finds so objectionable. “Well, the women... They jiggle,” he remarks. The film is hilariously accurate in its depiction of the censoring force having to attend every show and write down in explicit detail what is to be considered lewd and improper.

Reportedly, Friedkin's cut of The Night They Raided Minsky's was a considerably different film from the eventually released 1968 picture—Friedkin's first cut was, it was almost universally agreed, a complete disaster. Editor Ralph Rosenblum worked on the film in postproduction for over a year, finding a coherent film through his assiduousness. Some may assume the concept of cutting to old footage was Friedkin's idea—perhaps an homage to Jean-Luc Godard's stylistics—but it was indeed Rosenblum who came up with the idea himself. Rosenblum, in effect, re-directed the film himself and made an alternative version of Minsky's which is today the one actually seen.

Some of the film's finest moments are simply of Robards and Wisdom engaging in song and dance with one another. The soundtrack is stuffed with modern classics as well as some songs by Lee Adams (the score was provided by Charles Strouse). The agreeable combination Robards' wise-guy next to Wisdom's naïve optimist makes The Night They Raided Minsky's seem so effortlessly mounted, though it actually was one of Hollywood's most painful births; likewise, Robards' history as a great stage actor and Wisdom's history as a great British comedian and music-hall star must have paid dividends as they excel at projecting an immediacy that draws in a live audience. Minsky's isn't a grand time at the movies, but it is fast, fun and frank—a valentine to all things just vaguely fulsome.

43 comments:

art said...

gutter is a tool

Moses Hernandez said...

Never even heard of this one but you've got me interested, Alexander. Amazing that Rosenblum was able to make it into a coherent movie. Friedkin was weird. Still is I reckon.

Alexander Coleman said...

Thank you, Moses. It's worth seeing, but it makes me interested in what Friedkin's original cut may have held in store.

Harold said...

I remember seeing this some years back. I didn't think much of it but there were some good parts. Jason Robards was very underrated.

Alexander Coleman said...

Sounds like a common opinion, Harold. Robards is better here than he was given credit for at the time. Though I'm a little biased as a fan of his.

Sam Juliano said...

Yes, indeed, this is an appropriate April's Fool's Day post.

I can't say I was ever a fan of this film, but it does have some camp appeal. It's frivilous and often oncoherent as I recall, but I remember Joseph Wiseman generating laughs, and some of the stage routines are admittedly inspired as the film is a playful parody of burlesque. Indeed you say as much here:

"William Friedkin's second feature film is an uneven but sweet and charming ode to the 1920s theaters of burlesque."
Robards does deserve that lengthy career tribute you gave him here, and you may be right that his performance is better now that was originally thought of. I have seen this film in many years, so I'll have to check it out again.

I agree with your customary insights: that the film is about censorship's demise (or it's one of the first films to surface after that point)it attacks religion, and it has a lively soundtrack.

Hence, I must agree with you that's a passable piece. Kudos to Coleman's Corner for digging into teh vaults and brining out this curious and forgotten film. It's called 'diversity.'

Alexander Coleman said...

Thank you, Sam. I must say you continue to surprise me! Many people have never seen this film (and goodness knows there are still scores and scores and scores of films I must see, including a surprisingly high number on your list of great '60s films!).

Yes, the film does have some fairly considerable problems, but I tend to like it, and the performers are one of the main reasons. Robards is underrated here, and like you I do find Joseph Wiseman quite winning in his comic effort.

Thank you for the kind words again, and especially for noting the "diversity" for which I strive here, haha. Have a wonderful weekend.

merle said...

"If you're running' down my country, man, you're walkin' on the fightin' side of me."

Darvocet-N Generic said...

Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. This was actually what I was looking for, and I am glad to came here! Thanks for sharing the such information with us.

Enoch said...

Thanks for your article, quite effective info.
site

Nsmith said...

Nice post, thank you for sharing....

Matthew said...

This can't have effect in actual fact, that's exactly what I think.
Entertain recipes | limousine service in atlanta | university in nyc | rosary bracelets for men | matress

Nsmith said...

Nice post, thanks for sharing, Gastro Health Meds Nexium - Nexium Online!

Nsmith said...

Nice post, thanks for sharing, Antipsychotic Med Abilify - Abilify Online!

Nsmith said...

thanks for sharing,.. - Stablon Online!

blogcar said...

I remember seeing this some years back. I didn't think much of it but there were some good parts. Jason Robards was very underrated.
Marriage agencygratis dating

Nsmith said...

keep going... - Sildenafil Citrate Generic Viagra !

moonpharmacys said...

Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Very useful information particularly the last part :) I care for such information much. I was looking for this certain information for a long time. Thank you and good luck. rabeprazole price depression celexa

Otis said...

Really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us.Great site and a great topic as well i really get amazed to read this.
wholesale artificial grass

Nsmith said...

thanks for sharing... Pain Relief Darvocet-N !

Register website domain said...

I loved your post..I will visit very often..

Master in real estate said...

Thanks for the good work you did..

Darvocet said...

thanks for sharing... Pain Relief Darvocet !

Lipitor said...

thanks for sharing... Heart & Blood Pressure - Lipitor !

genericdrugshop said...

you’re in reality a just right webmaster. The website loading pace is amazing. It sort of feels that you are doing Generic Amoxil and buy nifedipineany distinctive trick. Also, The contents are masterwork. you have done a fantastic job on this matter!

Microzide said...

thanks for sharing... Heart & Blood Pressure - Microzide !

key said...

Do not trust amateurs Locksmiths in which the lower cost of operation is responsible of a lower quality performance. ключар

Advair Diskus said...

thanks for sharing... Advair Diskus - Advair Diskus !

klimatici said...

Whenever there is food residue in the dishes, throw them into the bucket before you put washing. отпушване на канали

key said...

In indeterminate outcome of the integration in a given area countries prefer to retain their sovereignty. електротехник

cinderella said...

Overcoming physical barriers is relatively the easiest електро услуги and generally ends at the scheduled time - late 1992.

cinderella said...

In the southern parts of the country's forests are sparse to be able to create tea and coffee plantations. With the importance of the industry is deodar, which serves for the manufacture of builders' carpentry, railway wagons and other bodies. дърводелски услуги

plumber said...

In this respect, declared emission standards of waste generated. Apply the Euro-1, and since 2005. and Euro-2 norms. смяна на щрангове

key said...

Entitled to send messages and recommendations to Parliament and to dissolve the Lok Sabha, to promulgate regulations at all times, except when both Houses вик ремонти of Parliament meet, make suggestions related to financial and money bills, to cancel or temporarily postponed the execution of sentences.

boiler said...

Is the state capital Bhopal, the official language is Hindi. The total area of ​​Madhya Pradesh is 308,000 km2. бойлери

Plavix said...

thanks for sharing... For Heart & Blood Pressure - Plavix !

cinderella said...

Air conditioners Mitsubishi Heavy are synonymous with style and innovation kachestsvo, ranking them in the forefront of the global market for air conditioners. мобилни климатици

klimatici said...

To delegate responsibility κλιματιστικά assessment performers themselves;

klimatici said...

It would be nice this section to be
ремонт на автоклиматици included in the job description for дограма more clarity on the issue of subordinate employees maids.

plumber said...

In this glass will pass both the
мобилни климатици heat and allow the heat inside the room.

cinderella said...

It can be found very wide selection for every taste and need. климатици

maya atanasova said...

In the last year opened a new ключарски услуги department stores and it unleashed retail.

key said...

Ensures the control of both климатици форум
temperature and humidity, preventing condensation климатизация